I had a conversation with my father a little while ago about Egypt. We often have these sorts of conversations when big things go on in the world. We are both only partially informed, and there is a lot of speculation, but I always find it interesting.
I asked my father how long he was in Egypt. "I was there three months. Some of the time in Aswan, working on an irrigation project at the Aswan Dam, and some time in Cairo. That was 50 years ago. The population of Cairo was 5 million or so at the time I think."
I asked him what he thought about what is going on in Egypt.
"I feel a little bit sorry for Mubarak. He has worked his whole life for Egypt." I talked about one of the blogs I have been reading, and how it sounded like the older generation has more sympathy for Mubarak, but the younger generation doesn't. I said " It is like the older generation can look with perspective, but the younger generation have simply had enough. They have lived with emergency law all their lives, they are educated and underemployed, they want opportunities. They have waited patiently all their lives, and they have had enough.
They have no space in their minds rational analysis, they are emotional and fed up."
We talked about what might be an option to move forward. I said "I think Mubarak should resign, but he should resign with some period of notice, and that they should lay out a plan for how a transition would take place, and have independant representatives vetting and monitoring that 'exit and transition'. Maybe they should be monitors from other middle east countries, and from figures that different sides trust." We agreed that there must be a way out of the gridlock, and that it must happen soon or it will get much worse.
I asked him whether he thought Mubarak has all his marbles still. " I think he does, but he is under an immense amount of pressure. We don't know what those with money are doing to influence and pressure him." I said that there is also a good chance that he is a bit emotional about it, and is not as able to think as clearly about it as he needs to. It is hard to let go of something you worked for your whole life."
My father said that he was worried about the rest of the middle east, and said he didn't think it would be a safe place to go for quite a while, after Tunisia, it is now Yemen, and Jordan, and now Algeria also demonstrating. He said " What I don't understand is what is happening in Iran? With things going off all over the middle east, when is Iran going to start? Maybe they are just waiting to see what happens?"
Obviously neither of us has any answers, but there is no one else I can have these conversations with. Sure there are others interested, but no one else who has both a personal connection to the region but is also willing to talk and discuss it.
Inchallah things get better.
I asked my father how long he was in Egypt. "I was there three months. Some of the time in Aswan, working on an irrigation project at the Aswan Dam, and some time in Cairo. That was 50 years ago. The population of Cairo was 5 million or so at the time I think."
I asked him what he thought about what is going on in Egypt.
"I feel a little bit sorry for Mubarak. He has worked his whole life for Egypt." I talked about one of the blogs I have been reading, and how it sounded like the older generation has more sympathy for Mubarak, but the younger generation doesn't. I said " It is like the older generation can look with perspective, but the younger generation have simply had enough. They have lived with emergency law all their lives, they are educated and underemployed, they want opportunities. They have waited patiently all their lives, and they have had enough.
They have no space in their minds rational analysis, they are emotional and fed up."
We talked about what might be an option to move forward. I said "I think Mubarak should resign, but he should resign with some period of notice, and that they should lay out a plan for how a transition would take place, and have independant representatives vetting and monitoring that 'exit and transition'. Maybe they should be monitors from other middle east countries, and from figures that different sides trust." We agreed that there must be a way out of the gridlock, and that it must happen soon or it will get much worse.
I asked him whether he thought Mubarak has all his marbles still. " I think he does, but he is under an immense amount of pressure. We don't know what those with money are doing to influence and pressure him." I said that there is also a good chance that he is a bit emotional about it, and is not as able to think as clearly about it as he needs to. It is hard to let go of something you worked for your whole life."
My father said that he was worried about the rest of the middle east, and said he didn't think it would be a safe place to go for quite a while, after Tunisia, it is now Yemen, and Jordan, and now Algeria also demonstrating. He said " What I don't understand is what is happening in Iran? With things going off all over the middle east, when is Iran going to start? Maybe they are just waiting to see what happens?"
Obviously neither of us has any answers, but there is no one else I can have these conversations with. Sure there are others interested, but no one else who has both a personal connection to the region but is also willing to talk and discuss it.
Inchallah things get better.

